2/20/2023 0 Comments Verdun free download full windows![]() So the French at Verdun surely could have identified the human remains by country, but they did not. Could it be that in the 1920s the French authorities at Verdun found 130,000 skeletons all without any vestige of uniform or dog tag or any other kind of army identification, whereas at the same time the number of such skeletons that the British CWGC were finding at Ypres was pretty close to zero? That doesn’t seem remotely credible, does it? Moreover, all soldiers wore metal ‘dog tags’ in a form particular to their army – the French even had two, at neck and wrist. Even if all the flesh was gone there would often be some uniform left. A few years after the fighting the bodies would not be nude skeletons. Many of the people who visit the ossuary and many who consult the internet sites come away with the following impression: After the War, many thousands of skeletons were found all over the battlefield since you can’t tell a German skull from a French one, no identification was possible, and so all the bones were put together in one great ossuary.īut that can’t be a true account, can it? If it was true, why didn’t the same apply on other battlefields, such as the Ypres or the Somme? At Ypres there are separate British and French and German cemeteries, which means that for pretty well every single body that was found there it was possible at the very least to tell which army the man had belonged to. I was puzzled by what my friends told me, and even more by what I found when I looked up some internet sites. They told me about the ossuary there: a building containing the bones of 130,000 unidentified French and German soldiers. Some friends were just back from visiting Verdun. My first posting seems to have raised not much interest, so I’ll try again. If it is not so, what is wrong with the above reasoning? If that is so, why don't I find that stated explicitly anywhere on any website, and why isn't it made clear to visitors to the monument? Therefore, I presume, the bones of 130,000 bodies were DELIBERATELY mixed together when the monument was made in the 1920s - even though it would have been possible to keep the French and German bodies mostly separate, had that been desired. If that were conceivable, you'd expect to find quite a few thousand such cases at Ypres yet, as far as I know, there aren't any graves there at all where the country of the dead man is undetermined. ![]() Surely it can't be true that all these 130,000 men were killed at Verdun in such a way that every vestige of their uniform disappeared. After talking to some friends just back from Verdun I'm puzzled about the Douaumont Ossuary.įrom my friends and from various websites I learn that the bones of 130,000 unidentified French and German soldiers are there - all mixed up together.Ī soldier may be 'unidentified', but that doesn't mean you can't tell which side he was fighting for.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |